Purpose cannot be funded through infrastructure, but it can be shaped.
The hardest question in the economy ahead is not money or power, but meaning. If the question "What do you do for a living?" is no longer the central question of identity, what takes its place? That question determines whether AI disruption is experienced as liberation or as loss. There is no technocratic answer.
Where do things stand today, and where do they break?
Paid work is today the central anchor of identity. "What do you do for a living?" is the first question at any first meeting. A career structures life stages, self-worth, social standing, even where people live and whom they choose as partners. Those who fall outside this system — the unemployed, the early-retired, the chronically ill, unpaid carers — experience it as a loss of identity, not merely material deprivation. This is visible in the data: Deaths of despair in the USA (the opioid crisis, suicides, alcohol: over 200,000 premature deaths per year since 2017), the Lying Flatmovement in China as a refusal of the 996 hyper-performance culture, anti-work communities on Reddit with 2.8m members. The mental health crisis is becoming structural: antidepressant prescriptions up 400% since 2000 in Switzerland, waiting times for therapy 12–24 weeks.
AI does not only substitute activity. It substitutes Significance. Those who defined their worth through paid work lose not only income when substituted, but also their sense of self. A triple amplifier adds to this: social isolation (Platform economy fragments the workforce), algorithmic comparison dynamics (Social media intensifies status anxieties), Loss of work-given life structure (no daily rhythm, no commuting phases, no break rituals). If this crisis of meaning is not actively addressed, a wave of political exploitation looms — from all sides and following the same pattern: meaning is replaced by the politics of scapegoating. The triple pressure of substitution, loss of meaning, and polarisation is not hypothetical. It is already under way.
Paths out of the crisis
The stars show how realistic a path is: 1 star = barely feasible, 5 stars = highly feasible.
Institutionalise the breadth of contributions.
Care, commons, culture, science, and art are recognised as equally valid forms of contribution, both institutionally and culturally.
+ Structural response, compatible with welfare-state logic.
Addresses the question of purpose only indirectly.
Trade-off: Material security vs. spiritual depth.
Feasibility: Connects Module 04 (Work & Contribution) with the question of meaning. A necessary condition, but not sufficient for the identity crisis. The Swiss cooperative tradition supports this.
Expand meaning infrastructure (mental health, community, rituals)
Structural investment in mental health provision, community spaces, transitional rituals (retirement, career disruptions) and psychological support.
+ Direct engagement with the crisis of meaning.
Difficult to scale; high staffing requirements.
Trade-off: Depth vs. breadth of provision.
Feasibility: Swiss pilots: Pro Senectute, Pro Juventute, Stiftung Sucht. The KVG minimum mental health standard (see Module 08) as an institutional foundation, supplemented by civil-society providers receiving federal funding.
Build culture / maker movement as an anchor of purpose
Open source, maker spaces, citizen science, and artistic and scientific self-organisation as culturally valued modes of contribution.
+ Meaning derived from creation, not consumption.
Accessible only to a self-motivated minority.
Trade-off: Deep identification vs. accessibility.
Feasibility: Mondragon, Mozilla Foundation, Wikipedia, and the open-source world as proof. In Switzerland: FabLabs, Citizen Science. A cultural task, difficult to promote through the state, but fundable.
Deliberately integrate the spiritual and religious dimension
Recognition that post-secular societies need spiritual anchors: mindfulness, religion (classical or new), and philosophical practice.
+ Addresses the deeper question of meaning.
Politically sensitive; conflict over secularism.
Trade-off: Identity formation vs. liberal value neutrality.
Feasibility: The US is experiencing a religious renaissance; China a Confucian one. Switzerland retains Reformed and Catholic traditions, both shrinking. The mindfulness movement and post-religious spirituality are growing. The phenomenon is not amenable to policy direction — and even less to be ignored.
Identity through consumption and leisure (market response)
The market supplies identity packages: lifestyle brands, travel, sport, entertainment, status symbols.
+ Scales without government intervention.
Buys meaning, does not create it.
Trade-off: Convenience vs. depth.
Feasibility: It works for the fortunate few with the means to pursue it, and fails everyone else. Not wrong in itself, but structurally insufficient as a model for society as a whole. Consumption-driven identity depletes resources without yielding genuine meaning.
Trigger-based phases
Trigger: Mental health waiting times in Switzerland exceed 24 weeks; the substitution wave is reaching mid-career knowledge workers.
2026–2029. The meaning crisis moves from a fringe social concern to mainstream debate. First federal initiatives to expand mandatory health insurance coverage to include mental health services. Platform backlash intensifies.
Trigger: A statutory minimum standard for mental health under health insurance law comes into force; the range of contributions is set by political mandate.
2029–2033. Mental health provision systematically expanded. Care, commons, and culture recognised as valid forms of contribution. Build-Culture federal funding launched. The shift in language begins: "What do you do" becomes "What are you working on".
Trigger: More than 40% of those in employment define contribution more broadly than paid work.
2033–2038. Identity models diversify. Build culture, maker spaces and citizen science become mainstream sources of purpose. Mental-health waiting times fall below six weeks. Spiritual and philosophical practice undergoes a renaissance. Schools integrate life-skills education more substantively.
Trigger: "What do you do for a living?" is an unusual, almost old-fashioned question.
2038+. Identity is no longer defined primarily by paid work. Breadth of contribution is normalised. The mental health crisis has been reduced to a structural level. The Swiss model serves as a European reference for identity beyond paid employment. The question of meaning remains open, but it has become one that human agency can shape.
Real-world pilot programmes
Where the ideas behind this pillar are already being tested. "Learn more" opens the explanation without leaving the page.
What we are watching
Mental health as a minimum standard. The threshold of fewer than 4 weeks marks systemic provision rather than crisis intervention.
Track in the index →Identity diversification. The 55% threshold marks the cultural shift: paid work is no longer the primary anchor for the majority.
Mental health indicator. A score below 8 is consistent with Scandinavian best-practice benchmarks.
Build-Culture as mainstream. The threshold of 250,000 corresponds to about 3% of the population, which is mainstream level for a subculture.
Track in the index →Our assessment
At Globalance, we consider the question of meaning the hardest one in the economy ahead: harder than tax reform, harder than the question of ownership, harder than climate policy. It has no technocratic answer. Meaning cannot be institutionalised like a pension reform; it must be cultural developed by many actors, across generations. But it can be enabled or prevented by infrastructure.
A four-layer strategy offers a viable path forward: Firstly Institutionalise breadth of contribution (Module 04): care, commons, culture and science as recognised forms of contribution. This is the structural precondition. Second Expand meaning infrastructure: mental-health provision, community spaces, transition rituals. This is the direct response. Third Strengthen Build Culture and the maker ethos: meaning from creation, not from consumption. Fourth treat spiritual and philosophical depth as a legitimate domain, not dismiss it as a private matter.
«What do you do for a living?» must give way to «What are you working on at the moment?». That sounds minor, but it is culturally substantial. A mother with caring responsibilities, a researcher at an open-source foundation, a cultural practitioner in a cooperative, a retired engineer as a citizen-science member: all four working towards something, yet only one has a «career» in today's language. Language must change before identities can.
Mental health is becoming critical infrastructure for the 21st century. Switzerland is structurally under-served: waiting times of 12–24 weeks for therapy places, and mental health not set as a minimum standard under the KVG. Globalance supports extending the KVG to include a mental-health minimum standard (first appointment within 4 weeks, therapy starting within 12 weeks), together with support for asynchronous mental-health platforms with quality assurance.
Two oversimplifications keep recurring. Both sound plausible, and both lead us astray. The first shortcut is: «A basic income solves the question of meaning.» It does not. Material security does not answer the question of one's own role; it merely poses it without time pressure. The second is: «Return to family and the work ethic of earlier decades.» That does not hold either. It assumes a world of work that no longer exists and leaves people with an expectation they cannot meet. Both shortcuts will accompany the coming years. Both miss the point.
Build culture and open-source ethos are the only cultural movements of the past 30 years that positive have broadly established non-employment-based forms of contribution. Wikipedia, Mozilla, Mondragon, FabLabs and citizen science all show that people want to contribute, create and work together. They need only the spaces, the tools and cultural recognition. The Swiss cooperative tradition (Migros, Coop, Raiffeisen, MIDATA) is well suited to connect with this.
Do not dismiss the spiritual dimension. Secular democracies struggle with the proposition that people need meaning beyond the material sphere. Empirically, however, the picture is clear: religious renaissance in the United States and China is real, and the mindfulness movement in Europe is growing. The Swiss position: no interference in matters of religious doctrine, but recognition that spiritual and philosophical practice forms part of the spectrum of meaning. Schools can strengthen ethics and personal development as compulsory subjects without becoming confessional.
What this means for investors: First, if paid employment loses weight, markets around purpose, community and health will grow: education, culture, physical activity and mental health. Second, a minimum standard for mental health care within basic insurance would raise demand for therapy and digital offerings. Quality and proven outcomes will decide who benefits. Third, makerspaces and research labs are rarely listed on stock exchanges, yet they shift demand for tools, materials and software. Fourth, companies that offer employees purpose and development retain their talent. In an economy with less routine work, that becomes a competitive advantage.
Why now: The substitution wave is under way. Any country that fails to address the question of meaning in the next 5 years will face a politically exploited meaning crisis in 10. Switzerland has the advantage of its cultural stability, its cooperative tradition and its institutional maturity. Those conditions do not exist in the same form in the United States or China. They should be used.
The strongest objection is fundamental: it is not the role of institutions to provide meaning. Any attempt to enable meaning through infrastructure comes close to prescribing how people should live. That proximity remains uncomfortable, regardless of who voices it. There is also a historical objection: the close link between paid work and identity is itself a product of the last two hundred years. It is possible that this link dissolves without any intervention from us, and that we are mistaking a transitional problem for a permanent crisis.
What we do not yet know
- Can meaning be promoted institutionally, or must it emerge culturally? And what is the role of the state?
- How do we balance value-neutral secularism with the acknowledgement of spiritual needs?
- How do we prevent the crisis of meaning from being exploited for populist ends — on both left and right?
- What role do established religions, mindfulness, and philosophical practice play in a post-secular Switzerland?
Connected to: 04 · Labour, 05 · Education, 08 · Care
Scenarios: Society & Psychology · Investment Implications · Labour & Automation
