Livelihoods must no longer depend on gainful employment.
As paid employment weakens as a distribution mechanism, new mechanisms are needed. Not a single universal remedy, but an intelligent combination.
Where do things stand today, and where do they break?
In Switzerland, around 8% of the population live in relative poverty; in Germany, 16%; in the United States, 11%. Today, basic livelihood security is provided almost entirely through two channels: wage labour plus conditional social benefits (unemployment benefit, social assistance, supplementary benefits). Both presuppose that paid employment is available and that need can be verified through administrative assessment. In Switzerland, the welfare state accounts for roughly 20% of GDP, compared with an OECD average of 27%. This architecture functions efficiently as long as full employment remains the baseline scenario.
If AI structurally replaces 15–30% of tasks (Acemoglu/Restrepo 2022, Brookings 2024) and retraining cannot keep pace, the result is structural unemployment: not cyclical, but permanent. Social-assistance architectures are not designed for this. They assume that unemployment is a temporary condition. If 20% of working-age people become long-term recipients, the system's legitimacy collapses.
Paths out of the crisis
The stars show how realistic a path is: 1 star = barely feasible, 5 stars = highly feasible.
Universal Basic Income (UBI)
Universal Basic Income (UBI) for all (Finland 2017, Stockton 2019, Swiss initiative 2016: 76.9% against).
+ Maximum simplicity — dignifying rather than demeaning.
– 30–40% of GDP required for a subsistence-level UBI in Switzerland; inflation risk for scarce goods.
Trade-off: Universality entails a significant fiscal burden.
Feasibility: The Swiss 76.9% rejection in 2016 was not accidental; it was a signal of acceptance limits. In its maximum form, political majority support is achievable only under crisis pressure, and full implementation is barely affordable economically.
Universal Basic Services (UGV)
Housing, healthcare, education, mobility, and internet provided free or heavily subsidised (UK NHS, Vienna with 60% of the housing market).
+ Directly addresses inflationary risk.
Paternalistic, with little freedom of choice.
Trade-off: Strong on scale goods, weak on individual needs.
Feasibility: Already exists in partial components (education, healthcare) on a wide scale. A political extension to housing, mobility, and internet is within the range of the possible. Sweden, Vienna, and Finland point the way.
Negative Income Tax (NIT)
Those who earn below a threshold receive a transfer from the state (Friedman 1962, US EITC since 1975).
+ Preserves work incentives; integrated with the tax system.
Breaks down in scenarios of the economy ahead where paid employment is no longer available.
Trade-off: A bridge, not a permanent architecture.
Feasibility: Established in several OECD countries. Politically uncontroversial to implement, as it preserves employment incentives and builds on existing tax infrastructure. Well suited as a Phase 1 component.
Capital Dividend (Citizens' Wealth Fund)
Citizens receive a Capital Dividend from a sovereign wealth fund (Alaska: $1,000–$2,000 per citizen per year since 1982).
+ Ownership stake, not handouts.
Rarely politically viable without a boom.
Trade-off: Works only if equity stakes are secured early.
Feasibility: Methodologically clear, politically sensitive: it requires state equity stakes in private companies. Viable in Switzerland with an AHV link.
Job Guarantee (Tcherneva)
The state guarantees a job offer in care, climate, or the commons (India NREGA, >250m households).
+ Purpose through contribution.
Make-work risk high.
Trade-off: Socially stable; costly when value added is low.
Feasibility: Tested in emerging-market contexts. Rare in OECD countries. Politically viable as a care-and-climate layer, because it addresses genuine fields of activity with demonstrable social need.
Trigger-based phases
Trigger: First OECD country introduces a Universal Basic Services component nationwide (e.g. free internet as a right or a national public transport flat rate)
Universal Basic Services is becoming politically normalised. The Swiss debate is shifting towards pragmatic expansion — public-transport flat rates, internet as a basic right. First Capital Dividend pilots are emerging in resource-rich jurisdictions.
Trigger: Swiss popular initiative for AHV 2.0 with a capital-stock component reaches the ballot
Hybrid models (NIT + Universal Basic Services + Capital Dividend) become standard in 3–5 OECD countries. Switzerland introduces a participation-fund mechanism. Care Job Guarantee established as a cantonal reform in 2–3 Swiss cantons.
Trigger: Basic income security in most countries is provided primarily through Universal Basic Services plus a Capital Dividend, no longer primarily through paid employment.
Earned income covers consumption above the base level. The political debate is shifting from "whether" to "how much". The generation entering the labour market after 2030 will know the old model only as history.
Real-world pilot programmes
Where the ideas behind this pillar are already being tested. "Learn more" opens the explanation without leaving the page.
What we are watching
Universal Basic Services becomes a normalised policy option.
Switzerland's housing issue is being addressed structurally, not merely in rhetoric.
The Alaska model is emerging as a benchmark for other jurisdictions.
Universal Basic Services initiative gains majority support, political window opens.
SWFs are becoming the dominant institutional buyers.
Our assessment
The question of 'Universal Basic Income or nothing' is the wrong framing. At Globalance, we see the end model as a hybrid architecture of three coordinated components. No single solution carries the weight alone.
The foundation consists of Universal Basic Services: housing, health, education, mobility, internet. These are where the scarcity-inflation risks of a pure cash transfer arise. If every citizen receives CHF 2,500 in Universal Basic Income (UBI), the housing market will absorb that within 18 months unless the housing question is addressed structurally. Universal Basic Services does exactly that. Vienna and the Scandinavian model show it can scale.
Built on a moderate base Capital Dividend from a sovereign AI fund. Not as a handout, but as a Capital Dividend paid out on an ownership stake that citizens hold in AI infrastructure. This is economically stable and psychologically decisive: being a shareholder is different from being a supplicant. The amount must be calibrated. We envisage CHF 4,000–6,000 per person per year in Switzerland, funded from the returns of a hypothetical sovereign holding fund of CHF 400–600bn.
As an optional third layer, a Job Guarantee in care, caring-work, and climate sectors. Those who wish to contribute should be able to, on terms that guarantee a livelihood and generate genuine value creation. This addresses the question of purpose while resolving the demographic care challenge.
UBI at maximum scale we consider politically unrealistic and economically risky. The 76.9% rejection by Swiss voters in 2016 was no coincidence, but a signal about the limits of public acceptance: majorities in western democracies expect a link between contribution and benefit. Universal Basic Income (UBI) severs that link without offering any compensating logic of meaning.
From a Swiss perspective the AHV is the natural anchor point. An "AHV 2.0" model with a substantial capital stock component and a Capital Dividend paid out to citizens is conceptually feasible and could command majority support. It draws on existing institutional trust — the AHV is Switzerland's most broadly accepted public institution — and sidesteps a debate that has not moved since the 1990s. Universal Basic Income has been contested for thirty years without any shift in majorities; working through existing institutions gets there faster.
Why now: Structural unemployment is not a future possibility. It is beginning now, in waves. The first waves are hitting knowledge-economy professions: banking, insurance, consulting. The second wave will hit service and logistics jobs. If income security is not decoupled from paid employment before the second wave arrives, pressure on democratic institutions will grow and simple answers will gain appeal.
The strongest objection comes from Universal Basic Income advocates, and it is not easy to dismiss. This architecture requires three components, three administrations, and three political majorities. Universal Basic Income requires one. Complexity in social policy is not a neutral feature. It creates application barriers, boundary disputes, and exactly the bureaucracy that erodes trust. A simple, costly system may well act faster than a well-conceived one that never comes into being.
What we do not yet know
- How does one prevent Universal Basic Services from becoming a two-tier system — where public means poor quality and private means good?
- How does one calibrate cash components so that inflation in scarce goods does not erode all gains?
- What political majority supports a hybrid architecture when the left wants Universal Basic Services, the right wants a Negative Income Tax, and both distrust Universal Basic Income (UBI)?
- Who controls a sovereign AI fund so that it does not become subject to political capture?
Connected to: 01 · Taxation, 03 · Value creation, 08 · Care, 10 · Purpose & identity
Scenarios: Labour & Automation · Society & Psychology · Economics & Capital
