Paid employment is only one form of contribution.
If AI substitutes 30 to 50% of today's knowledge work, social contribution can no longer be defined through paid employment alone. The spectrum of legitimate forms of contribution must be actively broadened. Care, the commons, culture and science are no less valuable — they were simply invisible because they commanded no market price.
Where do things stand today, and where do they break?
Paid employment is today the central measure of social recognition and material security. Care and domestic work (in Switzerland roughly 9.2bn unpaid hours per year, carried out mainly by women) is largely invisible in GDP. Platform workers such as Uber drivers, Deliveroo couriers, and click-workers operate in a legal grey zone where social benefits, protection from dismissal, and fair pay are systematically eroded. Platform cooperatives exist as a niche (Mondragon with about 70,000 members, Stocksy), yet account for under 1% of the platform market. A Job Guarantee as a concept is debated (US Stony Brook studies, MMT school) but is not institutionally embedded.
AI substitution hits junior- and mid-level knowledge work first: code, texts, research, standard analysis. When the classic career pyramid (Junior → Mid → Senior) ladder loses its base, the logic of advancement that underpins our understanding of paid employment breaks down. At the same time, care needs are growing demographically: Switzerland will need about 50,000 additional care workers by 2040, who cannot be recruited through the paid labour market. If we do not systematically revalue care and domestic work, and if we do not rethink paid employment as one Should society fail to redefine the forms of contribution, a dual crisis looms: economic (a shortage of care workers) and cultural (a loss of purpose for those whose labour has been displaced).
Paths out of the crisis
The stars show how realistic a path is: 1 star = barely feasible, 5 stars = highly feasible.
Job Guarantee in care, climate and education
The state acts as employer of last resort in strategic sectors: needs-driven, not industrial-policy-driven.
+ A direct lever that addresses two crises simultaneously.
Fiscally substantial (Switzerland ~CHF 12bn p.a.).
Trade-off: Security for workers vs. market flexibility.
Feasibility: The New Deal, Argentina's Plan Jefas y Jefes (2002) and India's NREGA (since 2005, 75m workers) demonstrate that such schemes work in times of crisis. Switzerland has the structural means; politically viable if linked to AHV reform.
Universal Right to Contribution
Every citizen has an institutional entitlement to a formally recognised form of contribution: paid work, care, platform cooperative, culture, or science.
+ Culturally strong, a source of identity.
Politically fraught question of who controls the definitions.
Trade-off: Inclusion vs. susceptibility to abuse.
Feasibility: Belgian Article 60 and the French employment-law model serve as templates. Switzerland has no tradition of state employment law. That makes it politically difficult, yet culturally viable if tied to co-operative logic.
Platform cooperatives entering the mainstream
Supporting platforms in the co-operative model: public seed capital plus a legal framework.
+ Market-compatible, democratically owned.
Capital-access constraint against well-capitalised competitors.
Trade-off: Works in niches; not universally applicable.
Feasibility: Mondragon, Up & Go NYC, and Stocksy are established niche successes. Switzerland's co-operative tradition — Migros, Coop, Raiffeisen — supports this. What is needed is federal seed funding and five to eight pilot sectors.
Negative Income Tax / contribution top-up
Friedman model: low earned income combined with a care/commons contribution is supplemented via a tax credit top-up.
+ Politically elegant and market-compatible.
Identity question remains unresolved.
Trade-off: Materially strong, culturally weak.
Feasibility: EITC USA since 1975, technically functional. But it reinforces the identity tied to paid work rather than replacing it. Suitable as a transitional mechanism, not as a target model.
Care civic service (compulsory service)
A mandatory care-service requirement spanning three life phases (young, mid-life, old age) as a social anchor.
+ Addresses the care deficit and questions of purpose.
Politically very difficult; conflict over the voluntary nature of participation.
Trade-off: Cultural strength vs. liberal values.
Feasibility: The Swiss civilian service model provides the conceptual reference point; the Israeli multi-year model serves as a benchmark. Beyond Switzerland and Israel, this would be politically extremely difficult. In Switzerland, it is conceivable only as an expansion of civilian service to encompass women, combined with a second service phase around the mid-fifties.
Trigger-based phases
Trigger: The first Swiss cantons launch a care Job Guarantee or AHV care recognition as a pilot.
2026–2028. Geneva, Neuchâtel or Basel-City as pioneers. First 1,000–3,000 care positions with a Job Guarantee, running in parallel with an AHV pilot recognising care hours. Platform co-operative fund included in the Federal Council's dispatch. Globalance investment focus: first-mover platforms with a co-operative element.
Trigger: AHV reform with care recognition is adopted (popular vote or Federal Decree).
2028–2032. Care hours become eligible for the AHV nationwide. The Job Guarantee is introduced in 8–12 cantons. The platform co-op fund begins to pay out, with the first 5 pilot sectors under way. Care and social work establishes itself culturally as a profession, not a sacrifice. An investment wave flows into care platforms.
Trigger: Right to Contribute is formalised as a constitutional amendment or legislation.
2032–2037. A universal right to recognised contribution — paid work, care, co-ops, culture, science — is anchored institutionally. Contribution accounts are introduced, analogous to learning accounts. Platform co-ops hold 8–15% market share in their pilot sectors. The care and social sector grows to 18% of paid employment.
Trigger: More than 30% of workers are engaged in care, commons, culture, or research as their primary contribution.
2037+. "Contribution" is established as a social concept; paid employment is one specific form among several. A broader definition of contribution reduces the meaning crisis to a local phenomenon. Care and support work could give rise to a distinct investment field in its own right.
Real-world pilot programmes
Where the ideas behind this pillar are already being tested. "Learn more" opens the explanation without leaving the page.
What we are watching
When care work and unpaid domestic labour is remunerated and accorded greater social recognition, the share doubles. A threshold of 18% marks this revaluation as a structural success.
Platform co-operatives moving from niche to visible market presence. The 8% threshold means co-ops are market-relevant in at least three sectors.
Care and care work is remunerated on a par with comparable work. The 90% threshold marks the end of structural care wage discrimination.
Care contributions reflected in pension entitlements. The CHF 4bn threshold corresponds to approximately 40% of today's unpaid care work, formally recognised.
Our assessment
At Globalance, we regard breadth of contribution as the most important cultural precondition of the economy ahead., more important than UBI or a robot tax. As long as paid employment remains the sole measure of social recognition, every instance of AI-driven labour substitution will be felt as a personal failure. Only when care, the commons, culture and science are recognised as equivalent forms of contribution are recognised, the substitution of human labour becomes socially manageable.
Viable is a Dual Strategy: above the Job Guarantee in care, climate and education as the institutional framework, below it the universal right to contribute as a cultural anchor. Platform cooperatives form a complementary market space that democratises ownership without nationalisation. Together, the two layers create a contribution structure that does not abolish paid employment but puts it in perspective. It becomes one of several legitimate forms.
Care work must count towards the AHV pension. This is the central Swiss lever. Today, hours spent on care effectively do not count towards a pension; that is the largest gender pay gap we have. An AHV reform that recognises care hours under clear criteria (dementia care, childcare, voluntary care work) as a pension-qualifying contribution would be fiscally manageable (~CHF 3bn p.a.) and culturally transformative.
Platform cooperatives are the market-compatible answer to platform monopolies. Switzerland has the cultural foundation, given its cooperative tradition (Migros, Coop, Raiffeisen, MIDATA). What is missing is capital for the start-up phase. A federal platform cooperative fund of CHF 200–400m, focused on five pilot sectors (care, continuing education, local logistics, creative work, eldercare), would be the pragmatic lever.
Paid employment remains a central pillar. This is not a conversation about abolition. But paid employment is being put in perspective: not every person finds meaning in it, and not every phase of life is optimised for it. A mother with care responsibilities, a researcher at an open-source foundation, a creative worker in a cooperative: all three contribute, and all three deserve institutional recognition beyond the tax return.
What this means for investors: First, if care work receives greater recognition in retirement provision, it creates purchasing power among people with little income today, with consequences for consumer and healthcare markets. Second, care and support services are growing regardless of policy, because the population is ageing. Providers, training, and technology in the care sector form a distinct investment field. Third, platform and cooperative models in social services could put existing providers under margin pressure. Fourth, companies that accommodate forms of contribution beyond paid employment, such as further education, flexible hours, or volunteering, are likely to have an advantage in attracting skilled staff.
Why now: The substitution is under way. Those who do not now build a broad institutional base for contribution will face a crisis of meaning in five years. They will also face those who want to turn that crisis into political capital. Switzerland has the advantage of its federal system: a start in two or three pilot cantons is possible without rebuilding the entire federal state. This window is closing, however.
The strongest objection is the price of recognition. Once care work, art, and common goods give rise to pension entitlements, someone must decide what counts. That creates an authority to assess activities that until now were free precisely because no one assessed them. There is a real risk that formalisation damages what it is meant to protect. The Job Guarantee has a second problem: it is only as good as the work it creates. Where it produces employment without discernible purpose, it deepens the crisis of meaning it was meant to solve.
What we do not yet know
- How can platform co-operatives be integrated into the Swiss system without distorting competition relative to private platforms?
- Can the right to contribute be harmonised internationally, or will it remain a nationally and culturally specific question?
- Who bears the fiscal transition costs of upgrading the status of care work: the federal government, the cantons, AHV contributors, or a wealth tax?
- How do we prevent a care Job Guarantee from becoming a mere make-work scheme, and how do we safeguard quality?
Connected to: 02 · Income, 05 · Education, 08 · Care, 10 · Meaning
Scenarios: Labour & Automation · Society & Psychology · Economics & Capital
