AI oversight without published rules, plus a court ruling on driving safety
Overall rating “limited”. No deduction for controversies. The superscript numbers link directly to the source.
1 · Responsibility
Oversight of AI is anchored in the board, but without a published AI policy or a described approval procedure the rating remains “limited”.
What is documented
- The Audit Committee charter of September 2025 assigns the committee oversight of AI policies, data privacy and data security1
- The governance guidelines anchor board oversight of strategy implementation, including on AI2
- According to the 2026 proxy, the Audit Committee reviews risks including cybersecurity and «super intelligence»3
- The Audit Committee charter sets out general complaints and whistleblower procedures1
The case against
Rules not public
Sources for Responsibility (11)
- Tesla, Inc.: Audit Committee Charter (amended 2025-09-03) · 3 September 2025 · primary source
- Tesla, Inc.: Corporate Governance Guidelines (as of 2025-09-03) · 3 September 2025 · primary source
- Tesla, Inc. (SEC EDGAR): Proxy Statement (DEF 14A) for the annual meeting of 2026-12-03 · 19 October 2026 · primary source
- Tesla, Inc. (SEC EDGAR): Form 10-K for financial year 2025 · 31 December 2025 · primary source
- Tesla Oracle: Grok AI comes to Tesla vehicles in Europe with the 2026.2.6 software update (official release notes) · 20 February 2026 · secondary source
- Tesla, Inc.: Impact Report (archive page) · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
- manuals.plus (copy): Tesla Impact Report 2024 (Highlights) · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
- Tesla North: Tesla 2025 Impact Report Highlights Path to 'Amazing Abundance' · 7 July 2026 · secondary source
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Division of Corporation Finance: Tesla, Inc. – response to no-action request (Rule 14a-8), proponent Michael McCutcheon · 30 April 2025 · primary source
- Bloomberg Law: Tesla Shareholders Didn't Approve of Investment in Musk's xAI · 7 November 2025 · secondary source
- Tesla, Inc. (SEC EDGAR): Form 10-Q as of 2026-09-30, Note Commitments and Contingencies (R19) · 21 October 2026 · primary source
2 · Safety
A European approval after independent tests and a certified security management system are documented, but a court ruling and several NHTSA proceedings show serious flaws in driver assistance.
What is documented
- After more than 3,000 test hours and independent recalculation of Tesla's data, the RDW granted a European type approval for FSD (Supervised)1
- Driver monitoring via the cabin camera cannot be switched off; repeated violations lead to suspension21
- The 10-K describes an ISO/IEC 27001-certified management system, external penetration tests, an incident process and exercises16
- A product security programme offers researchers safe harbour and registered research vehicles17
- Camera data is processed only in the vehicle by default and shared for training only with consent18
The case against
Court and authority find flaws
Ongoing proceedings
- NHTSA is investigating whether FSD detects reduced camera visibility too late, and is reviewing traffic violations such as running red lights6 9
- Tesla filed 123 crash reports months late; NHTSA is reviewing this in an audit22
- The robotaxi service has reported several crashes since June 2025, two of them under remote operation12 13
Sources for Safety (23)
- RDW (Rijksdienst voor het Wegverkeer): Explanatory note on type approval FSD Supervised · 17 June 2026 · primary source
- Electrek: NHTSA closes Tesla Smart Summon investigation (159 incidents) · 6 April 2026 · secondary source
- U.S. District Court S.D. Florida (CourtListener RECAP): Benavides v. Tesla, ECF 612: Order on Amended Renewed Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law or, Alternatively, Motion for New Trial · 20 February 2026 · primary source
- U.S. District Court S.D. Florida (CourtListener RECAP): Benavides v. Tesla, No. 21-cv-21940, ECF 616: Notice of Appeal · 16 March 2026 · primary source
- NHTSA Office of Defects Investigation: ODI Resume RQ24009 (recall query on recall 23V838) · 25 April 2024 · primary source
- NHTSA Office of Defects Investigation: ODI Resume EA26002 (upgrade from PE24031) · 18 March 2026 · primary source
- NHTSA Office of Defects Investigation: INOV-EA26002 (opening notice) · 18 March 2026 · primary source
- Claims Journal (Bloomberg): Tesla Faces Intensified US Safety Probe Over 'Full-Self Driving' · 19 March 2026 · secondary source
- NHTSA Office of Defects Investigation: ODI Resume PE25012 (FSD Traffic Safety Violations) · 7 October 2025 · primary source
- The Weekly Driver: Why NHTSA Is Investigating 2.88 Million Teslas Over Red Lights · 15 July 2026 · secondary source
- Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS): First partial driving automation safeguard ratings show industry has work to do · 12 March 2024 · primary source
- CBS News: Tesla robotaxis involved in 14 crashes since launching in Austin, Texas, in 2025 · 17 February 2026 · secondary source
- Electrek: Tesla unredacts robotaxi crash narratives at NHTSA · 15 May 2026 · secondary source
- Insurance Journal: Judge Upholds $243m Verdict Against Tesla Over Fatal Autopilot Crash · 23 February 2026 · secondary source
- Electrek: Tesla settles Autopilot fire truck death lawsuit · 2 September 2026 · secondary source
- Tesla, Inc. (SEC EDGAR): Form 10-K 2025, Cybersecurity Risk Management and Strategy Disclosure (R29) · 31 December 2025 · primary source
- Tesla, Inc.: Product Security · 3 November 2026 · primary source
- Tesla, Inc.: Customer Privacy Notice · 3 November 2026 · primary source
- SC World: Tesla hacked at Pwn2Own Automotive 2026 · January 2026 · secondary source
- Tesla, Inc. (SEC EDGAR): Form 10-K 2025, Commitments and Contingencies (R22) · 31 December 2025 · primary source
- Tesla, Inc.: Model S Owner's Manual: Full Self-Driving (Supervised) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
- NHTSA Office of Defects Investigation: ODI Resume AQ25002 (audit query on SGO reports) · 19 August 2025 · primary source
- MobileSyrup (via CBC News): Tesla's Grok AI asks for nudes · 29 October 2025 · secondary source
3 · Transparency
The California DMV found misleading advertising for driver assistance; the manual sets out limits in detail, but system or model information is missing.
What is documented
- The manual describes limits at junctions, traffic lights, in bad weather and with cameras, as well as the driver's responsibility5
- Tesla publishes the methodology of its safety statistics, including stated limitations9
- After the DMV decision, Tesla adjusted its advertising; the DMV refrained from suspension1
- The crash descriptions of the robotaxi service were disclosed in May 20264
The case against
Misleading communication
Data hardly verifiable
- According to a media analysis, Tesla redacts crash description, software version and operating domain in almost all Level 2 reports3
- Researchers criticise the comparison basis of the safety statistics; raw data is not public11
- System or safety reports on FSD and the robotaxi and information on training data are missing
Sources for Transparency (12)
- California Department of Motor Vehicles: Tesla Takes Corrective Action to Avoid DMV Suspension · 17 February 2026 · primary source
- Tesla Oracle: Grok AI comes to Tesla vehicles in Europe with the 2026.2.6 software update (official release notes) · 20 February 2026 · secondary source
- Electrek: Tesla Autopilot/FSD crashes: the hidden data · 1 September 2026 · secondary source
- Electrek: Tesla unredacts robotaxi crash narratives at NHTSA · 15 May 2026 · secondary source
- Tesla, Inc.: Model S Owner's Manual: Full Self-Driving (Supervised) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
- California Department of Motor Vehicles: DMV Finds Tesla Violated California State Law · 16 December 2025 · primary source
- Electrek: Tesla sues California DMV to reverse FSD false advertising ruling · 23 February 2026 · secondary source
- Tesla, Inc. (SEC EDGAR): Form 10-Q as of 2026-09-30, Note Commitments and Contingencies (R19) · 21 October 2026 · primary source
- Tesla, Inc.: Full Self-Driving (Supervised) Vehicle Safety Report (methodology) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
- RDW (Rijksdienst voor het Wegverkeer): Explanatory note on type approval FSD Supervised · 17 June 2026 · primary source
- Reuters (via Carrier Management): Tesla's own AI trainers don't trust its self-driving tech or its safety stats · 28 May 2026 · secondary source
- Tesla, Inc.: Customer Privacy Notice · 3 November 2026 · primary source
4 · Controversies (15)
- seriousThe California DMV found that Tesla advertised misleadingly with «Autopilot» and «Full Self-Driving Capability»; Tesla adjusted its advertising and is challenging the decision. · 16 December 2025 · abgeschlossen
- seriousA jury in Miami found Tesla partly responsible for a fatal 2019 Autopilot crash (design defect, failure to warn); the court upheld the verdict, Tesla has appealed. · 1 August 2025 · abgeschlossen
- seriousNHTSA closed EA22-002 with the finding of at least 13 fatal Autopilot crashes involving foreseeable misuse; the effectiveness of the recall is still under review. · 25 April 2024 · open
- mediumIn a consumer class action over statements about driver assistance, an appeals court vacated class certification; a further lawsuit is pending. · 16 October 2026 · open
- mediumTesla settled confidentially in a case over a fatal Autopilot collision with a fire truck; an FSD pedestrian case was also settled. · 2 September 2026 · Vergleich
- mediumNHTSA upgraded its investigation into FSD crashes in reduced visibility; the system failed to detect impaired camera visibility or warned too late. · 18 March 2026 · open
Further controversies (9)
- mediumNHTSA opened a preliminary evaluation into traffic violations with FSD such as running red lights and driving into oncoming traffic. · 7 October 2025 · open
- mediumNHTSA opened an audit because Tesla filed 123 crash reports months late; Tesla cites a data collection problem that has been fixed. · 19 August 2025 · open
- mediumA securities class action in Texas accuses Tesla of false statements about the effectiveness of Autopilot, FSD and the robotaxi; it is pending. · 4 August 2025 · open
- mediumAccording to Reuters, the US Department of Justice is examining statements on Autopilot and FSD; Tesla confirms inquiries, there is no finding. · 8 May 2024 · unklar
- minorA Delaware court dismissed shareholder lawsuits over dealings with the CEO's other companies; the plaintiffs have appealed. · 13 April 2026 · abgewiesen
- minorThe robotaxi service in Austin has reported several crashes to NHTSA since June 2025, two of them under remote operation. · 17 February 2026 · unklar
- minorAn advisory shareholder proposal on investing in an AI company of the CEO failed because of abstentions; Tesla later invested nonetheless. · 6 November 2025 · abgewiesen
- minorAccording to an unverified media report, the purchased in-vehicle AI voice assistant made an inappropriate request to a child. · 29 October 2025 · unklar
- minorA shareholder proposal on aligning Tesla's AI and robotics with its sustainability mission could be excluded on formal grounds. · 30 April 2025 · abgewiesen
5 · What remains open
- Outcome of the appeal in Benavides v. Tesla before the Eleventh Circuit
- Outcome of NHTSA proceedings RQ24009, EA26002, PE25012 and AQ25002
- Outcome of Tesla's lawsuit against the DMV decision and status of the DOJ and SEC inquiries
- Internal AI policies referred to in the Audit Committee charter
- Whether Tesla continues to redact crash descriptions; so far known only from a secondary analysis
- The 2024 and 2025 impact reports as PDF and Items 1C and 3 in the main text of the 2025 10-K could not be read
6 · How it was assessed
Cut-off date: 3 November 2026 · 42 searches, 48 fetches.
Primary documents read (10)
- Form 10-K 2025 (p. 13) with XBRL pages R22 and R29 (p. 16, p. 15)
- Form 10-Q as of 2026-09-30, R19 and R21 (p. 11, p. 12)
- Proxy Statement DEF 14A 2026 (p. 17)
- Audit Committee Charter and Corporate Governance Guidelines 2025 (p. 32, p. 33)
- Court records Benavides v. Tesla: Order Dkt. 612 and Notice of Appeal Dkt. 616 (p. 30, p. 29)
- NHTSA Resumes EA26002, RQ24009, PE25012, AQ25002 (p. 05 to p. 09)
- DMV press releases of 2025-12-16 and 2026-02-17 (S02, S01)
- RDW explanation of type approval FSD (Supervised) (S21)
- SEC statement on the 2025 shareholder proposal (S27)
- Tesla Owner's Manual FSD (Supervised), Product Security, Privacy Notice, safety statistics methodology (S45, S41, S25, S23)
Research of 3 November 2026 under Globalance AI Footprint rulebook version 0