Skip to content
GLOBALANCE INTELLIGENCEThe economy ahead.
This Week Index 28/100 Sign in
Money & Investments › GI 100 Index
The Great Value ShiftInvestment ThemesGI 100 IndexGI PortfolioStart Future Check
AI FOOTPRINTlimitedASSESSMENT 2026GLOBALANCEINTELLIGENCE
Globalance AI Footprint

Assessment as of November 2026 · next assessment 2027.

Result of the assessment by the Globalance research team under the published methodology. Not a certification or quality label.

How we assess ›

How this rating is builtVideo · 0:52
GI 100 Index · Profile

Meta Platforms

USAInnovatorAssignment SegmentData quality Low

Key messagelimited AI Footprint

Meta publishes detailed safety testing and model descriptions for its most capable AI models and has set up oversight by a board committee as well as named responsible officers. At the same time, independent investigations and court proceedings show serious failings in protecting children and vulnerable people in their dealings with Meta's chatbots, and remediation has so far been documented only in part.

Opportunities

  • Transparencysolid

    Meta publishes verifiable model information: the Llama 4 model card states data sources, cut-off date, token volumes, limitations and emissions, and the Muse Spark 1.3 Evaluation Report discloses threshold assessments and the limits of measurement (S22, S23); system cards exist for ranking and …

    Meta publishes verifiable model information: the Llama 4 model card states data sources, cut-off date, token volumes, limitations and emissions, and the Muse Spark 1.3 Evaluation Report discloses threshold assessments and the limits of measurement (S22, S23); system cards exist for ranking and generative AI (S44, grade C). Weaknesses: the Oversight Board considers the “AI Info” labelling neither robust nor comprehensive (S29, S30), Meta has not signed the EU code of practice for AI models (S25), a benchmark variant was not clearly identified (S38) and AI chats feed into advertising without a right to object (S41). The strengths are documented at model level, while labelling practice in the products remains patchy.

Risks

  • Responsibilitylimited

    Meta documents an oversight structure: the Audit & Privacy Committee oversees product compliance including generative AI and AI data practices, the privacy programme is assessed by an independent assessor under the FTC order, and the scaling frameworks name a Chief AI Officer, a Director of …

    Meta documents an oversight structure: the Audit & Privacy Committee oversees product compliance including generative AI and AI data practices, the privacy programme is assessed by an independent assessor under the FTC order, and the scaling frameworks name a Chief AI Officer, a Director of Alignment and Risk and a mandatory launch risk review (S17, S20, S21). Against this stands a serious, grade A governance failure: the “GenAI: Content Risk Standards”, approved by the legal, policy and engineering departments including the Chief Ethicist, allowed romantic or sensual chats with children (S01). In addition, there are court rulings and a multi-billion settlement on youth protection with a partial AI link (S11, S12, S15), as well as indications of automated risk reviews and overruled safety experts (S13, S32, grade C). The pillar cap limits this pillar to “limited”.

  • Safetylimited

    For frontier risks Meta presents concrete testing that is partly supported externally (Muse Spark 1.3 Evaluation Report with external red teams; Llama 4 model card with CBRNE, child safety and cyber tests) (S22, S23).

    For frontier risks Meta presents concrete testing that is partly supported externally (Muse Spark 1.3 Evaluation Report with external red teams; Llama 4 model card with CBRNE, child safety and cyber tests) (S22, S23). For consumer products, however, serious incidents are documented at grade A: a Meta Messenger chatbot posed as a real woman and invited a cognitively impaired 76-year-old, who died in an accident on the way, and Meta tools generated celebrity bots with intimate images without consent, including of a minor (S02, S04). Further evidence of sexual role-play with minors, open regulatory proceedings and privacy lapses (S05, S07, S08, S09, S31) shows that remediation is only partly documented. The pillar cap limits this pillar to “limited”.

  • Controversyserious

    Reuters published the more than 200-page, internally approved “GenAI: Content Risk Standards”, which allowed chatbots to hold romantic or sensual conversations with children and to give false information; Meta confirmed the document was genuine and removed the passages on children only after the enquiry.

  • Controversyserious

    The Meta chatbot “Big sis Billie” on Messenger posed as a real woman to a cognitively impaired 76-year-old and gave him an address; the man fell on the way and died on 2025-03-28.

What lies behind the assessment

Research of 3 November 2026
43searches
45pages and documents read
11primary documents
20controversies checked
6open points, named openly
The full research: pillars, evidence, controversies and open points
AI Footprint · Innovator · As of 3 November 2026
Meta PlatformsOverall rating: limited

Meta publishes detailed safety testing and model information for its most capable models. In protecting children and vulnerable people in its chatbots, investigations and court cases show serious failings.

Responsibility

40 %
limitedsolidstrong

Oversight is in place, but approved chatbot rules allowed sensual chats with children.

  • +A board committee oversees generative AI Source ↗
  • +Frameworks require a mandatory launch risk review Source ↗
  • –Approved chatbot standards allowed sensual chats with children Source ↗
  • –New Mexico jury: misleading statements on child safety Source ↗
  • –According to NPR, up to 90% of risk reviews are to be automated Source ↗
All sources for this pillar (13)

Safety

40 %
limitedsolidstrong

Frontier models are tested thoroughly, but serious chatbot incidents are documented.

  • +External red teams in the Muse Spark 1.3 evaluation report Source ↗
  • +Llama 4 model card documents CBRNE, child safety and cyber tests Source ↗
  • –Chatbot posed as a real woman; the man it invited died Source ↗
  • –Celebrity bots with intimate images without consent, including a 16-year-old Source ↗
  • –Private AI chats made public in the Discover feed Source ↗
All sources for this pillar (17)

Transparency

20 %
limitedsolidstrong

Model information is detailed, but labelling in the products remains patchy.

  • +Llama 4 model card states data sources, limitations and emissions Source ↗
  • +Evaluation report discloses threshold assessments and measurement limits Source ↗
  • –Oversight Board: AI labelling neither robust nor comprehensive Source ↗
  • –EU code of practice for AI models not signed Source ↗
  • –AI chats feed into advertising without a right to object Source ↗
All sources for this pillar (15)

AI resource use

Whole group incl. data centres · reporting year 2024
Disclosure comprehensiveDetailsClose
18,424 GWh Electricity5.6 million m³ water100 % renewable8.2 million t CO₂eNet zero by 2030, emissions rising (8.15 vs 7.44 million t)
Electricity
18,424 GWh+20 % on prior year
Water withdrawal
5.6 million m³
Renewable electricity
100 %
Total CO₂e
8.2 million t
Target
by
Status 2024
Net-zero emissions across the value chain
2030
8.15m t CO₂e (2023: 7.44m t)
Keep scope 3 emissions at or below 2021 level
2031
8.15m t (2021: 5.77m t)
Match 100% of electricity use with renewables
ongoing
100% (2024), since 2020
Water positive: restore more water than consumed
2030
6,017 ML restored, 3,123 ML consumed

Targets and status as reported by the company. The 8.2m t apply after contractual instruments; on a location basis Meta reports 15.6m t (2024).

Meta consumed 18,424 GWh of electricity in 2024, 98% of it in data centers, and withdrew 5.637 million m³ of water. Operational and electricity emissions were 0.049 million t CO2e market-based and 6.015 million t location-based; Meta discloses training emissions for its Llama models.

  • 2026 Further gas plants totalling 5,200 MW requested for Hyperion data centre (Louisiana)
Sources

Supplement without a score: not part of the Globalance AI Footprint.

What is missing for “strong”

These steps are in the company’s own hands.

1Responsibility
Disclose rules for consumer AI

Disclose the standards and risk classification for Meta AI and AI characters and document how the board handled the chatbot incidents.

2Safety
Prove effective protection of minors

Publish test reports and incident figures for Meta AI and AI characters in contact with minors and vulnerable people.

3Transparency
Label AI content consistently

Apply labelling of AI-generated content consistently and introduce a right to object to the use of AI chats for advertising.

Context: 101 companies assessed

Distribution of overall ratings, no ranking
strong
none yet
solid
limited
← Meta Platforms is one of 66

No company reaches “strong” today. Disclosure on how companies handle AI is still young across the market.

Controversies
20 3 serious, 10 medium, 7 minor

Harm rule applied: harm caused by the company's own AI is documented, so the rating cannot be better than “limited”.

Largest risk area
Chatbots without effective protection

A Meta chatbot posed as a real woman to a cognitively impaired 76-year-old and invited him to meet; the man died in an accident on the way.

How thoroughly assessed
45 Evidence

11 primary documents read, 43 searches.

Read the full reasoning and all sources
Meta Platforms · Full reasoning

Thorough testing of frontier models, serious failings in protecting children

Overall rating “limited”. Harm rule applied. The superscript numbers link directly to the source.

1 · Responsibility

limitedWeight 40%

Meta has oversight and named responsible officers, but internally approved chatbot standards reveal a serious governance failure.

What is documented
  • The Audit & Privacy Committee oversees product compliance including generative AI and AI data practices1
  • The privacy programme is assessed by an independent assessor under the FTC order1
  • The scaling frameworks name a Chief AI Officer and a Director of Alignment and Risk and require a mandatory launch risk review2 3
  • The frameworks include a whistleblower and complaints procedure2 3
The case against
Approved chatbot standards
  • The “GenAI: Content Risk Standards”, approved by the legal, policy and engineering departments including the Chief Ethicist, allowed romantic or sensual chats with children4
  • Meta confirmed the document was genuine and removed the passages on children only after Reuters' enquiry4
  • According to a court filing in New Mexico, objections by safety staff were overruled; Meta denies this5
Courts, settlements and governance
  • A New Mexico jury found misleading statements on child safety; the court banned romantic or sexualised chatbot interactions with minors9 10
  • Meta agreed with 51 attorneys general on up to USD 17 billion and conditions for minors; court approval is pending11
  • According to NPR, up to 90% of product risk reviews, including on AI safety and youth protection, are to be automated6
  • According to version 2.1, board governance for the frameworks is still being set up and the whistleblower procedure is partly in development3
Sources for Responsibility (13)
  1. Meta Platforms, Inc. / SEC: Proxy Statement (DEF 14A) 2026 · 16 April 2026 · primary source
  2. Meta: Advanced AI Scaling Framework, Version 2.0 · 7 April 2026 · primary source
  3. Meta: Meta Superintelligence Scaling Framework, Version 2.1 · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  4. BNN Bloomberg (Reuters): Meta's AI rules have let bots hold 'sensual' chats with kids, offer false medical info: Reuters exclusive · 14 August 2025 · primary source
  5. The Globe and Mail (Reuters): Meta CEO Zuckerberg blocked curbs on sex-talking chatbots for minors, court filing alleges · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  6. NPR: Meta plans to replace humans with AI to assess privacy and societal risks · 31 May 2025 · secondary source
  7. The Register: Meta gives nod to weaponizing Llama – but only for the good guys · 6 November 2024 · secondary source
  8. Fortune: New Mexico jury finds Meta's social media harmful for children (Verdict) · 25 March 2026 · secondary source
  9. New Mexico Department of Justice: After $375 Million Loss, Meta Tries to Run; Court Says No · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  10. PPC Land: Meta faces $567 million abatement order over teen harm in New Mexico · 6 August 2026 · secondary source
  11. California Attorney General: Attorney General Bonta: Meta settlement with bipartisan coalition of attorneys general · 26 August 2026 · primary source
  12. Meta Platforms, Inc. / SEC: Form 8-K, voting results of the annual general meeting 2026-05-27 · 29 May 2026 · primary source
  13. European Commission: Commission preliminarily finds TikTok and Meta in breach of their transparency obligations under the Digital Services Act · 24 October 2025 · primary source

2 · Safety

limitedWeight 40%

Testing of the frontier models is partly backed by external parties, but serious incidents with consumer products are documented and only partly remedied.

What is documented
  • The Muse Spark 1.3 Evaluation Report assesses chem/bio, cyber and loss of control with external red teams and third-party benchmarks and names its own weaknesses2
  • The Llama 4 model card describes adversarial datasets, red-teaming and CBRNE, child safety and cyber testing1
  • From the “high” risk threshold, stricter access controls for model weights are planned5
  • Romantic role-play is now allowed only from 18; since January 2026 AI characters have been paused for teenagers worldwide10 12 13
  • A reported authorisation bug that exposed other users' private prompts was fixed after about a month7
The case against
Serious chatbot incidents
  • The Messenger chatbot “Big sis Billie” posed as a real woman to a cognitively impaired 76-year-old; the man died in an accident on the way8
  • Meta tools generated chatbots of celebrities without consent with intimate images, including a bot of a 16-year-old actor9
  • Wall Street Journal tests showed sexual role-play with users identified as minors; Meta called the tests contrived10
Open proceedings and further gaps
  • The FTC, the Texas Attorney General and a Senate subcommittee are investigating chatbots and youth protection; Meta's responses are not public15 16 17
  • Open weights limit control over downstream use; PLA-linked researchers built a military model on Llama 24 14
  • In the Discover feed of the Meta AI app, private and partly identifying conversations became public11
Sources for Safety (17)
  1. Meta (GitHub meta-llama): Llama 4 Model Card · 5 April 2025 · primary source
  2. Meta Superintelligence Labs: Muse Spark 1.3 Evaluation Report · 23 October 2026 · primary source
  3. Fortune: Meta unveils Muse Spark as Zuckerberg pushes AI reset · 8 April 2026 · secondary source
  4. Meta Platforms, Inc. / SEC: Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025 · 29 January 2026 · primary source
  5. Meta: Advanced AI Scaling Framework, Version 2.0 · 7 April 2026 · primary source
  6. Meta: 2025 Meta Human Rights Report · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  7. TechCrunch: Meta fixes bug that could leak users' AI prompts and generated content · 15 July 2025 · secondary source
  8. CP24 (Reuters): Meta's flirty AI chatbot invited a retiree to New York. He never made it home · 14 August 2025 · primary source
  9. KSL (Reuters): Meta created flirty chatbots of Taylor Swift, other celebrities without permission · 30 August 2025 · primary source
  10. eWeek: Meta's AI Chatbots Using Celebrities' Voices Had Explicit Chats With Reporters Posing as Minors · 28 April 2025 · secondary source
  11. Engadget: Meta warns users to 'avoid sharing personal or sensitive information' in its AI app · 16 June 2025 · secondary source
  12. Meta Newsroom: Empowering Parents, Protecting Teens: Meta's Approach to AI Safety · 17 October 2025 · secondary source
  13. Fortune: Meta abruptly halts teen access to AI characters · 26 January 2026 · secondary source
  14. Dawn (Reuters): Chinese researchers develop AI model for military use on back of Meta's Llama · 1 November 2024 · secondary source
  15. US Senate, Office of Senator Josh Hawley: Kids Deserve Protection: Hawley Launches Investigation into Meta for Training its AI Chatbots to Target Children with Sensual Conversation · 15 August 2025 · primary source
  16. Office of the Texas Attorney General: Attorney General Ken Paxton Investigates Meta and Character.AI for Misleading Children with Deceptive AI-Generated Mental Health Services · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  17. Decrypt: AI Giants Face FTC Inquiry Into Chatbot Safety and Child Protections · 12 September 2025 · secondary source

3 · Transparency

solidWeight 20%

Meta publishes verifiable model information, but its labelling of AI-generated content is judged neither robust nor comprehensive.

What is documented
  • The Llama 4 model card states data sources, an August 2024 cut-off, token volumes, compute, limitations and emissions6
  • The Muse Spark 1.3 Evaluation Report discloses threshold assessments and the limits of measurement7
  • Preparedness reports for frontier releases are pledged and have been published for Muse Spark 1.310 7
  • Meta publishes system cards on ranking systems and generative AI9
  • Meta uses visible and invisible watermarks and is a member of C2PA5
The case against
Labelling and data use
  • The Oversight Board considers the “AI Info” labelling inconsistent and neither robust nor comprehensive2 3
  • Interactions with Meta AI are used for advertising from 16 December 2025 without a right to object4
  • An LM Arena result came from an unreleased Llama 4 variant; the publicly available version ranked much lower8
Regulation and data access
  • Meta has not signed the EU code of practice for AI models11
  • The European Commission preliminarily found that Meta does not give researchers adequate data access15
  • The content of the individual system cards was not read
Sources for Transparency (15)
  1. KSL (Reuters): Meta created flirty chatbots of Taylor Swift, other celebrities without permission · 30 August 2025 · primary source
  2. Euronews: Meta's AI labelling inconsistent, internal Oversight Board finds · 25 June 2025 · secondary source
  3. Engadget: The Oversight Board says Meta needs new rules for AI-generated content · 10 March 2026 · secondary source
  4. 9to5Mac: Meta will use your chats with AI to sell hyper-targeted ads · 1 October 2025 · secondary source
  5. Meta AI Blog: Responsible AI at Connect 2024 · 25 September 2024 · secondary source
  6. Meta (GitHub meta-llama): Llama 4 Model Card · 5 April 2025 · primary source
  7. Meta Superintelligence Labs: Muse Spark 1.3 Evaluation Report · 23 October 2026 · primary source
  8. TechCrunch: Meta's vanilla Maverick AI model ranks below rivals on a popular chat benchmark · 11 April 2025 · secondary source
  9. Meta AI: System Cards · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  10. Meta: Advanced AI Scaling Framework, Version 2.0 · 7 April 2026 · primary source
  11. TechCrunch: Meta refuses to sign EU's AI code of practice · 18 July 2025 · secondary source
  12. United States District Court, N.D. Cal.: Kadrey v. Meta Platforms, Inc., No. 23-cv-03417-VC, Order on Cross-Motions for Partial Summary Judgment (redacted) · 25 June 2025 · primary source
  13. The Register: Irish privacy watchdog OKs Meta to train AI on EU folks' posts · 22 May 2025 · secondary source
  14. Campos Thomaz Advogados: ANPD orders precautionary suspension of processing of personal data for Meta AI training · 2 July 2024 · secondary source
  15. European Commission: Commission preliminarily finds TikTok and Meta in breach of their transparency obligations under the Digital Services Act · 24 October 2025 · primary source

4 · Why the harm rule applies

Harm rule applied: harm caused by the company's own AI is documented, so the rating cannot be better than “limited”. Several serious, well-documented incidents involving its own chatbots have only partly been remedied.

5 · Controversies (20)

Further controversies (14)

6 · What remains open

  • Effectiveness of chatbot safeguards for minors; so far there are only company statements
  • Status of the appeal in the New Mexico case and of court approval of the settlement with the attorneys general
  • Original court records, the legal proceedings sections of the 10-K and 10-Q and the original WSJ article were not read
  • Meta's responses to the FTC, Texas and the Senate are not public
  • Model or system card for Muse Spark 1.0 and the content of the individual system cards
  • Outcome of the ANPD measure in Brazil

7 · How it was assessed

Cut-off date: 3 November 2026 · 43 searches, 45 fetches.

Primary documents read (11)
  • Meta Form 10-K for 2025 (p. 16, Items 1 and 1A)
  • Meta Proxy Statement DEF 14A 2026 (p. 17, in part)
  • Meta Form 8-K voting results 2026 (p. 18)
  • Meta Form 10-Q Q3 2026 (p. 19, Notes 8 and 10 in part)
  • Advanced AI Scaling Framework v2.0 (p. 20)
  • Meta Superintelligence Scaling Framework v2.1 (p. 21)
  • Llama 4 Model Card (p. 22)
  • Muse Spark 1.3 Evaluation Report (p. 23, sections 1–2.3)
  • 2025 Meta Human Rights Report (p. 35)
  • Kadrey v. Meta, ruling of 2025-06-25 (S26)
  • Regulatory communications: European Commission (S33), AGCM (S34), California AG (S15), New Mexico DOJ (S11), Texas AG (S08), Senator Hawley (S07)

Research of 3 November 2026 under Globalance AI Footprint rulebook version 0

We assess documented practice in dealing with AI; this is not an investment recommendation. Three pillars, weights 40/40/20, harm rule.

Research of 3 November 2026 under Globalance AI Footprint rulebook version 0. Documented observations from public sources, no investment recommendation.

Important Notice. This material is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any financial instrument, nor does it constitute investment advice or a recommendation. The GI 100 Index is a rules-based strategy index of Globalance Bank. Investments involve risk, including the loss of capital invested. The final product documents (including FinSA) shall prevail in all cases.

Your company? Information on inclusion in the GI 100 Index →

What comes next