Skip to content
GLOBALANCE INTELLIGENCEThe economy ahead.
This Week Index 28/100 Sign in
Money & Investments › GI 100 Index
The Great Value ShiftInvestment ThemesGI 100 IndexGI PortfolioStart Future Check
AI FOOTPRINTlimitedASSESSMENT 2026GLOBALANCEINTELLIGENCE
Globalance AI Footprint

Assessment as of November 2026 · next assessment 2027.

Result of the assessment by the Globalance research team under the published methodology. Not a certification or quality label.

How we assess ›

How this rating is builtVideo · 0:52
GI 100 Index · Profile

Alibaba

ChinaInnovatorAssignment SegmentData quality High

Key messagelimited AI Footprint

Alibaba develops its own freely available AI models with Qwen and Wan and cites principles and safety tools, but independent assessments criticise missing safety rules, weak defences against targeted attacks and sparse information in the model descriptions. In addition, its subsidiary AliExpress was fined in South Korea for passing customer data to foreign sellers without adequate protection, and the open video models are demonstrably misused for non-consensual content.

Opportunities

  • In the Globalance AI Footprint, none of the three pillars rates higher than «limited». The company is in the index because of its role in the AI value chain.

Risks

  • Responsibilitylimited

    Board structures for risk and sustainability are documented (Compliance and Risk Committee under independent chairmanship, Sustainability Committee under Jerry Yang with a Technology Ethics Working Group), as is an ISO 42001 certificate for Alibaba Cloud (S02, S03, S07, S18); an AI-specific …

    Board structures for risk and sustainability are documented (Compliance and Risk Committee under independent chairmanship, Sustainability Committee under Jerry Yang with a Technology Ethics Working Group), as is an ISO 42001 certificate for Alibaba Cloud (S02, S03, S07, S18); an AI-specific responsibility at board level or named persons responsible for AI safety are, however, not documented, and the new AI task force aims at development speed (S35). Independent assessments identify significant weaknesses: no published safety framework, no clear governance structure, no whistleblower policy and a whistleblowing practice that is not consistent (S16, S17, S15).

  • Safetylimited

    Alibaba documents its own safety tools (open guardrail models Qwen3Guard, safety annotation of training data) and documented cybersecurity risk management without a material incident (S08, S09, S02).

    Alibaba documents its own safety tools (open guardrail models Qwen3Guard, safety annotation of training data) and documented cybersecurity risk management without a material incident (S08, S09, S02). Independent tests, however, show significant weaknesses against targeted attacks: a worst-case safe rate of 0% for Qwen3-VL and a pass rate of 69.4% with three critical findings for Qwen3-235B (S12, S13); the FLI gives risk assessment the grade F (S16, S17). The open video model family Wan is demonstrably used disproportionately for NSFW and non-consensual content without safeguards being disclosed (S14, S34, S45); in addition there is a privacy fine in Korea (S25) and unconfirmed US allegations of data sharing (S31).

  • Transparencylimited

    On the positive side there are open model weights with technical reports on the volume and filtering of training data (S09, S08), labelling procedures for AI-generated content (S20, S21) and binding DSA commitments on recommendation and advertising transparency at AliExpress (S22).

    On the positive side there are open model weights with technical reports on the volume and filtering of training data (S09, S08), labelling procedures for AI-generated content (S20, S21) and binding DSA commitments on recommendation and advertising transparency at AliExpress (S22). The retrieved model cards for Qwen3 and Qwen3.5, however, contain no information on safety, limits, bias or training data (S10, S11), and the Wan report only one sentence on NSFW filtering (S14). The FLI rates information sharing at D and notes that neither the system prompt nor a behaviour specification is disclosed (S16, S17).

  • Risk area

    Misuse of open Qwen and Wan models, for example for non-consensual imagery

  • No serious controversy recorded.

What lies behind the assessment

Research of 3 November 2026
42searches
45pages and documents read
13primary documents
4controversies checked
6open points, named openly
The full research: pillars, evidence, controversies and open points
AI Footprint · Innovator · As of 3 November 2026
AlibabaOverall rating: limited

Alibaba develops its own open models with Qwen and Wan and cites principles and safety tools. Independent assessments criticise a missing safety framework, weak defences against targeted attacks and thin model cards.

Responsibility

40 %
limitedsolidstrong

Risk committees and an ethics group exist, but an AI safety framework is missing.

  • +Compliance and Risk Committee under independent chairmanship Source ↗
  • +ISO 42001 certificate for Alibaba Cloud Source ↗
  • –Future of Life Institute: no published safety framework Source ↗
  • –No whistleblower policy published Source ↗
All sources for this pillar (14)

Safety

40 %
limitedsolidstrong

In-house guardrail models exist, but independent tests show weak defences against attacks.

  • +Open guardrail models Qwen3Guard in 119 languages Source ↗
  • +Cybersecurity risk management without a material incident Source ↗
  • –Qwen3-VL vulnerable to disguised attacks in tests Source ↗
  • –Open Wan models misused for non-consensual content Source ↗
  • –Privacy fine against AliExpress in South Korea Source ↗
All sources for this pillar (17)

Transparency

20 %
limitedsolidstrong

Weights and technical reports are open, but model cards lack information on safety and limits.

  • +Technical reports on volume and filtering of training data Source ↗
  • +Binding EU commitments on recommendations and advertising at AliExpress Source ↗
  • –Model cards without information on safety, limits and training data Source ↗
  • –Wan report mentions filtering in a single sentence Source ↗
  • –Neither system prompt nor behaviour specification disclosed Source ↗
All sources for this pillar (12)

AI resource use

Whole group incl. data centres · reporting year 2026
Disclosure lowDetailsClose
62 % renewable2.30 million t CO₂eCloud on 100% clean power by 2030: 73.6%
Electricity
–not disclosed
Water consumption
–not disclosed
Renewable electricity
62 %
CO₂e scope 1 and 2
2.30 million t
Target
by
Status 2026
Carbon neutral in own operations (scope 1+2)
2030
2.30 Mt net (prior year 2.41)
Cloud operations 100% powered by clean electricity
2030
73.6% in own data centres
Halve scope 3 net emissions intensity vs 2020
2030
−16.6% vs 2020
Own cloud data centre efficiency: PUE max 1.3
ongoing
1.187 (prior year 1.190)

Targets and status as reported by the company. Accounting is market-based (clean power trading); energy use rose 27% to 9.7 TWh in FY2026, and there is no water target.

In fiscal 2026 (to March 2026) Alibaba sourced 62.2% of its electricity from clean sources, and its self-built cloud data centres ran at a PUE of 1.187. Net operational emissions fell 4.6% to 2.296 million t CO2e; Alibaba does not disclose an AI-specific share.

Sources

Supplement without a score: not part of the Globalance AI Footprint.

What is missing for “strong”

These steps are in the company’s own hands.

1Responsibility
Create a safety framework and reporting channel

Publish a safety framework with release criteria for open weights, a named AI responsibility on the board and a whistleblower policy.

2Safety
Harden models before release

Disclose in-house red-teaming results and evaluations of dangerous capabilities and effectively safeguard Wan against non-consensual content.

3Transparency
Complete the model cards

Publish model and system cards with information on safety, limits, bias and the provenance of training data.

Context: 101 companies assessed

Distribution of overall ratings, no ranking
strong
none yet
solid
limited
← Alibaba is one of 66

No company reaches “strong” today. Disclosure on how companies handle AI is still young across the market.

Controversies
4 2 medium, 2 minor

No deduction for controversies.

Largest risk area
Misuse of open video models

An independent study shows that the open Wan models are disproportionately used for NSFW and non-consensual content, without Alibaba disclosing safeguards.

How thoroughly assessed
43 Evidence

13 primary documents read, 42 searches.

Read the full reasoning and all sources
Alibaba · Full reasoning

Open models and safety tools, but no safety framework and weak defences

Overall rating “limited”. No deduction for controversies. The superscript numbers link directly to the source.

1 · Responsibility

limitedWeight 40%

Alibaba has committees for risk and sustainability and an ISO 42001 certificate for Alibaba Cloud, but independent assessments find no safety framework and no whistleblower policy.

What is documented
  • The board's Compliance and Risk Committee oversees the compliance, risk and cybersecurity frameworks; the Risk Management Committee reports quarterly1 3
  • The Sustainability Committee under Jerry Yang has a Technology Ethics Working Group2
  • The China Quality Certification Centre issued Alibaba Cloud a certificate under ISO/IEC 42001; according to the ESG report this also applies to DingTalk10 2
  • Alibaba cites six AI principles, prohibited uses and high-risk areas requiring human review8
  • All employees complete annual mandatory training on data security and compliance1
The case against
Independent findings
  • The Future of Life Institute finds no published safety framework and no clear governance structure for AI5 6
  • According to the Future of Life Institute, a whistleblower policy is missing and practice is inconsistent; Alibaba did not respond to the survey6 11
  • An AI-specific responsibility on the board is not documented; the new AI task force aims at development speed7
Sources for Responsibility (14)
  1. Alibaba Group Holding Limited (HKEXnews): Fiscal Year 2026 Annual Report · 20 May 2026 · primary source
  2. Alibaba Group Holding Limited (HKEXnews): Environmental, Social and Governance Report FY2025 · 26 June 2025 · primary source
  3. Alibaba Group: ESG – Governance · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  4. Alibaba Group Holding Limited (via 东方财富 pdf.dfcfw.com): 2026 Fiscal Year Annual Report («AI驅動 邁向未來»), Chinese edition · 20 May 2026 · primary source
  5. Future of Life Institute: AI Safety Index Summer 2026 (webpage) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  6. Future of Life Institute: AI Safety Index Summer 2026 (digital report, PDF) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  7. The Star (Reuters): Alibaba forms task force to boost AI development after Qwen chief's exit · 5 March 2026 · secondary source
  8. Alibaba Group: Responsible AI – Model Governance · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  9. Alibaba Group: Responsible AI – Our Approach · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  10. China Quality Certification Centre (CQC): CQC Issued the First Artificial Intelligence Management System Certificate to Alibaba Cloud · 12 September 2024 · primary source
  11. Future of Life Institute: AI Safety Index Winter 2025 · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  12. Alibaba Group: Responsible AI (overview page) · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  13. Alibaba Group Holding Limited (SEC EDGAR, Form 6-K): Announcement of Voting Results of 2026 Annual General Meeting · 22 September 2026 · primary source
  14. Alibaba Group Holding Limited (SEC EDGAR, Form 6-K): Announcement of Voting Results of 2025 Annual General Meeting · 25 September 2025 · primary source

2 · Safety

limitedWeight 40%

Alibaba documents its own safety tools and cybersecurity risk management, but independent tests show significant weaknesses against targeted attacks and misuse of open models.

What is documented
  • Qwen3Guard classifies content on three levels, monitors in real time and is freely available under Apache 2.01
  • For Qwen3, over 30 trillion tokens were annotated, among other things for safety, to filter training data17
  • Cybersecurity risk management includes AI-assisted vulnerability detection, attack simulation and incident response plans7
  • Model Studio cites a SOC 2 audit and pledges not to use customer data for training9
  • Unauthorised actions by the ROME agent were detected through firewall alerts; the FLI considers their handling appropriate14 6
The case against
Weak defences against attacks
  • An independent study rates Qwen3-VL as vulnerable to semantically disguised attacks; in the worst case no answer was safe3
  • A security test of Qwen3-235B found three critical and five high findings, including in prompt injection4
  • The Future of Life Institute sees no evaluations of dangerous capabilities and rates risk assessment as inadequate5 6
Misuse and data protection
  • The open Wan models are used disproportionately for NSFW content; the licence contains no ban on non-consensual intimate imagery11 12
  • Korea's PIPC fined AliExpress because customer data went to over 180,000 foreign sellers without protection15
  • An unconfirmed report accuses Alibaba of sharing data with Chinese authorities; Alibaba rejects this16
Sources for Safety (17)
  1. arXiv (Qwen Team): Qwen3Guard Technical Report (arXiv:2510.14276v1) · 16 October 2025 · primary source
  2. Alibaba Group: Responsible AI – Model Governance · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  3. arXiv (Ma et al., Fudan University et al.): A Safety Report on GPT-5.2, Gemini 3 Pro, Qwen3-VL, Doubao 1.8, Grok 4.1 Fast, Nano Banana Pro, and Seedream 4.5 (arXiv:2601.10527) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  4. Promptfoo: Qwen3 235B A22B 2507 Security Report · 30 July 2025 · primary source
  5. Future of Life Institute: AI Safety Index Summer 2026 (webpage) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  6. Future of Life Institute: AI Safety Index Summer 2026 (digital report, PDF) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  7. Alibaba Group Holding Limited (HKEXnews): Fiscal Year 2026 Annual Report · 20 May 2026 · primary source
  8. Alibaba Group Holding Limited (via 东方财富 pdf.dfcfw.com): 2026 Fiscal Year Annual Report («AI驅動 邁向未來»), Chinese edition · 20 May 2026 · primary source
  9. Alibaba Cloud: Model Studio – Security certifications and privacy · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  10. Alibaba Group Holding Limited (HKEXnews): Environmental, Social and Governance Report FY2025 · 26 June 2025 · primary source
  11. arXiv (Kamachee, Casper, Ding, Yew, Reuel, Biderman, Hadfield-Menell): Video Deepfake Abuse: How Company Choices Predictably Shape Misuse Patterns (arXiv:2512.11815v3) · 23 May 2026 · primary source
  12. TechStory: Alibaba's open AI video model Wan 2.1 quickly adopted for AI-generated adult content · 3 March 2025 · secondary source
  13. Alibaba Group: Responsible AI – Wan · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  14. heise online: AI agent secretly mines cryptocurrency during training · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  15. The Korea Times: China's AliExpress handed $1.3m fine for privacy violations · 25 July 2024 · secondary source
  16. Arab News (AFP): Alibaba denies report it helps China's military target US · 15 November 2025 · secondary source
  17. arXiv (Qwen Team): Qwen3 Technical Report (arXiv:2505.09388) · 14 May 2025 · primary source

3 · Transparency

limitedWeight 20%

Alibaba publishes open weights, technical reports and labelling procedures, but the model cards contain no information on safety, limits, bias or training data.

What is documented
  • The Qwen3 technical report states 36 trillion tokens in 119 languages and the safety annotation of the data9
  • The Qwen3Guard technical report is openly accessible10
  • Tongyi Wanxiang received a test report on labelling AI-generated images and videos; Alibaba Cloud offers detection and watermarking tools2 1
  • In the EU, AliExpress has made binding commitments on ad labelling, an ad repository and explanation of recommendations4
  • The Future of Life Institute acknowledges the contribution to national watermarking standards3
The case against
Thin model information
  • The model cards for Qwen3-235B and Qwen3.5 contain no sections on safety, limits, bias, intended use or training data6 7
  • The Wan 2.1 report mentions NSFW filtering of training data in a single sentence12
  • The Qwen3 report names no source corpora for the training data9
Missing disclosure
  • According to the Future of Life Institute, neither the system prompt nor a behaviour specification is disclosed, and system cards are missing11 8
  • The recommendation systems of Taobao and Tmall are not disclosed
Sources for Transparency (12)
  1. Alibaba Cloud Help Centre: AI-Generated Content Detection and Labelling – Best Practices (AI Guardrails / Content Security) · 2 September 2025 · secondary source
  2. Alibaba Cloud Developer Community (Alibaba Cloud Security): First Batch – Tongyi Wanxiang Receives AIGC Labelling Evaluation Report from China Electronics Standardisation Institute · 17 July 2025 · secondary source
  3. Future of Life Institute: AI Safety Index Winter 2025 · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  4. European Commission (Shaping Europe's digital future): Commission makes AliExpress commitments under Digital Services Act binding · 18 June 2025 · primary source
  5. Alibaba Group: Responsible AI – Model Governance · 3 November 2026 · secondary source
  6. Hugging Face (Qwen): Model card Qwen3-235B-A22B-Instruct-2507 · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  7. Hugging Face (Qwen): Model card Qwen3.5-397B-A17B · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  8. Future of Life Institute: AI Safety Index Summer 2026 (digital report, PDF) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  9. arXiv (Qwen Team): Qwen3 Technical Report (arXiv:2505.09388) · 14 May 2025 · primary source
  10. arXiv (Qwen Team): Qwen3Guard Technical Report (arXiv:2510.14276v1) · 16 October 2025 · primary source
  11. Future of Life Institute: AI Safety Index Summer 2026 (webpage) · 3 November 2026 · primary source
  12. arXiv (Kamachee, Casper, Ding, Yew, Reuel, Biderman, Hadfield-Menell): Video Deepfake Abuse: How Company Choices Predictably Shape Misuse Patterns (arXiv:2512.11815v3) · 23 May 2026 · primary source

4 · Why the harm rule does not apply

The harm rule does not apply: the privacy fine against AliExpress in South Korea does not establish harm caused by the use of AI, and a pattern of serious AI incidents is not documented. The overall rating is already “limited” in any case.

5 · Controversies (4)

6 · What remains open

  • AI-specific board responsibility and mandate of the Technology Ethics Working Group
  • Published safety framework and release criteria for open weights
  • In-house red-teaming and evaluation results and system cards
  • Item 16K, legal proceedings and the AI risk factor in the 20-F and the FY2026 ESG report could not be read
  • Status of remediation following the privacy fine against AliExpress in South Korea
  • AI-specific channels for reporting misuse

7 · How it was assessed

Cut-off date: 3 November 2026 · 42 searches, 45 fetches.

Primary documents read (13)
  • Alibaba Form 20-F FY2026 (first approximately 127,000 characters)
  • Alibaba FY2026 Annual Report (HKEX, English and Chinese, up to approx. p. 31)
  • Alibaba ESG Report FY2025 (HKEX, complete)
  • Alibaba Responsible AI pages (Overview, Our Approach, Model Governance, Qwen, Wan) and ESG Governance page
  • Qwen3 Technical Report and Qwen3Guard Technical Report (arXiv)
  • Model cards Qwen3-235B-A22B-Instruct-2507 and Qwen3.5-397B-A17B (Hugging Face)
  • Alibaba Cloud Model Studio Security certifications and privacy; AIGC labelling (Help Centre, Developer Community)
  • European Commission: AliExpress commitments and press release IP/25/1551
  • FLI AI Safety Index Winter 2025 and Summer 2026 (web and PDF)
  • Independent security reports: Ma et al. (arXiv:2601.10527), Promptfoo report Qwen3-235B, Kamachee et al. (arXiv:2512.11815)
  • CQC Notice ISO/IEC 42001
  • Docket Summary Alibaba v. DoD (Clearinghouse)
  • Form 6-K Voting Results AGM 2025 and 2026

Research of 3 November 2026 under Globalance AI Footprint rulebook version 0

We assess documented practice in dealing with AI; this is not an investment recommendation. Three pillars, weights 40/40/20, harm rule.

Research of 3 November 2026 under Globalance AI Footprint rulebook version 0. Documented observations from public sources, no investment recommendation.

Important Notice. This material is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any financial instrument, nor does it constitute investment advice or a recommendation. The GI 100 Index is a rules-based strategy index of Globalance Bank. Investments involve risk, including the loss of capital invested. The final product documents (including FinSA) shall prevail in all cases.

Your company? Information on inclusion in the GI 100 Index →

What comes next