Skip to content
GLOBALANCE INTELLIGENCEThe economy ahead.
This Week Index 28/100 Sign in
Countries › Switzerland
SwitzerlandGermanyChinaUSA
← All 14 pillars of SwitzerlandCountries › Switzerland › Pillar 10 of 14
PILLAR 10 · PEOPLE · SWITZERLAND

Individual: Purpose & Identity

Switzerland: Under developmentSwitzerland module · People

The militia system and associational culture are anchors for meaning beyond paid employment. This strength has not yet been recognised as such.

01 · STATUS QUO & FAULT LINE

Where does Switzerland stand, and where are the fault lines?

STATUS QUO

In Switzerland, paid employment is more than a source of income. It is the central anchor for status, daily structure and self-image. At the same time, the militia system, around 100,000 associations and a high share of voluntary work form dense networks of unpaid engagement. Swiss identity is strongly defined by paid employment, yet the country also possesses an exceptionally dense web of structures that provide meaning beyond the pay cheque.

FAULT LINE

As automation reduces the scope and self-evidence of paid work, many people lose their familiar answer to the question of their own contribution. Among young people, rising mental health pressures are already visible today, before the labour market has fundamentally changed. When the job disappears as the primary source of meaning, the existing alternative structures determine whether the result is freedom or disorientation.

02 · POLICY OPTIONS

Pathways for Switzerland

A
Strengthening and raising the profile of the militia system and voluntary work★★★★☆ 4/5

Switzerland actively elevates unpaid engagement in militia roles, associations and voluntary work — through recognition, accreditation and the reduction of bureaucratic burdens, for example. The militia system is a unique institutional asset. It gives citizens concrete responsibility and thus meaning outside their profession. As paid employment shrinks, this system can redirect freed-up time into community contribution. Identity then remains tied to action without depending solely on the labour market.

+ Builds on a real, deeply rooted Swiss institution rather than artificially inventing new structures of meaning.
– The militia system is already suffering from a shortage of recruits, and appeals alone do not automatically raise participation.

Trade-off: Social cohesion and a sense of purpose weighed against the risk that unpaid engagement places additional demands on already overburdened individuals.

Feasibility: Works only if recognition becomes tangible in material and temporal terms — otherwise, any upgrading of status amounts to little more than empty rhetoric.

B
Establish time-banking models nationwide★★★★★ 5/5

Switzerland is scaling time-banking systems in which care hours provided today are credited towards one's own future care. The St Gallen model known as Zeitvorsorge ("time provision") demonstrates how voluntary care work can be institutionally anchored and secured as a credit over time. For an ageing society with a shrinking volume of paid employment, this approach combines purpose, social contribution, and security. It makes care work visible and gives it enduring value beyond monetary wages.

+ Combines a sense of purpose, social cohesion and pension provision within a single, already proven model.
– Scaling beyond municipal boundaries raises questions about the portability and long-term guarantee of accumulated time credits.

Trade-off: Strengthening informal care weighed against the administrative burden of reliably administering time credits over decades.

Feasibility: The highest-leverage option among those available, as it directly couples purposeful activity with concrete long-term security.

C
Mental health and education for a life beyond employment★★★★☆ 4/5

Switzerland invests in mental health and in education that does not define identity through occupation alone. Given the growing pressures on young people, prevention matters before the transformation of the working world takes full effect. Education would be directed more strongly towards self-efficacy, relationships and social contribution rather than employability alone. This builds inner resources to find meaning even without a fixed job.

+ Addresses the root cause and enables people to draw identity from multiple sources rather than from their profession alone.
– Impact materialises only over a generation and is difficult to measure, which makes political prioritisation challenging.

Trade-off: Long-term resilience of the population weighed against the disadvantage that benefits and costs are far apart in time.

Feasibility: An indispensable foundation, but too slow as a standalone measure to cushion acute disruptions.

D
Rely on spontaneous market adjustment★★☆☆☆ 2/5

The state refrains from active intervention and trusts that new forms of work and meaning will emerge on their own. The market-adjustment approach assumes that people and the economy will reorient themselves, as they have in earlier disruptions. For Switzerland this is risky, because the loss of paid employment affects mental health before new structures take hold. Without preventive action, a gap may open between the disappearing job and the still-absent alternative.

+ Avoids costly policy misdirection and leaves room for unforeseen, bottom-up solutions.
– Ignores the fact that loss of purpose and identity takes effect immediately, while new structures emerge only with a lag.

Trade-off: State restraint and flexibility weighed against the risk of a social and psychological vacuum during the transition period.

Feasibility: Underestimates that Switzerland's existing structures of meaning, while present, do not automatically grow in step without active cultivation.

03 · TIME HORIZON

Trigger-based phases

Phase 1: Creating Visibility

Trigger: The first occupational groups experience a tangible loss of relevance due to automation.

Unpaid care work, militia roles and associational activity are recorded statistically and publicly recognised as social value. At this stage the aim is to make sources of meaning beyond paid work visible and open to debate.

Phase 2: Anchoring Structures

Trigger: Newly available time intersects with existing engagement structures at scale.

Time-credit models are rolled out across regions. Militia roles become more attractive through reduced burdens and formal accreditation. Education and mental health promotion are aligned with a life that includes less paid employment.

Phase 3: Recalibrating Identity

Trigger: Paid employment is no longer the default primary source of status.

Social contribution, relationships and self-efficacy carry identity on an equal footing with profession. Switzerland establishes a self-understanding in which value is not defined by paid work alone.

04 · PILOT PROGRAMMES

Real-world pilot programmes

Switzerland · Time Credits St. Gallen

Status: in operation since 2014

The Zeitvorsorge Foundation ("time provision") of the City of St Gallen enables volunteers to provide care hours for older people, crediting those hours against their own future care needs. The model anchors care work institutionally and gives voluntary engagement an enduring, secured value.

Open project

Switzerland · Militia system and association culture

Status: Established, facing a shortage of new recruits.

From local councils to sports clubs, hundreds of thousands of volunteers sustain public and social life in Switzerland. This established structure is a reservoir of purpose and responsibility. In the economy ahead it can grow in importance, but it needs deliberate cultivation.

Open project

Model from abroad · Fureai Kippu (Japan), to be examined as a model for Switzerland

Status: Operational abroad

In Japan, volunteers accumulate time credits through Fureai Kippu for caring for older people, which they can later redeem for themselves or family members. Switzerland should examine how elements of this nationwide system could be integrated with existing local time-banking models.

Open project

05 · EARLY INDICATORS

What we are watching

Voluntary participation rate

The rate measures whether the structures of meaning beyond paid employment hold up. A decline would signal that, as employment contracts, its substitute erodes rather than grows. A rise points to a successful redirection of freed-up time. For the debate about the economy ahead, this is the central early indicator of social resilience.

Today: Around one quarter of the population engages in formal voluntary work
→
Threshold: A marked and sustained decline in participation
Mental health among young people

This indicator shows how strongly questions of orientation and meaning are already felt before the major labour market shift arrives. Deterioration reveals that identity built on performance alone is fragile. It signals that alternative structures are needed more urgently than unemployment figures suggest. For policymakers it is a measure of how pressing preventive investment has become.

Today: Stress levels and demand for mental health treatment among young people are rising sharply
→
Threshold: Further deterioration despite existing employment opportunities
Prevalence of time-banking models

The spread of these models shows whether purposeful care work can be embedded in institutions. Where models remain local islands, societal scale is missing. Where they become portable and cross-regional, a genuine new structure of meaning and security emerges. The indicator thus measures the scalability of one of the most promising responses.

Today: Individual municipalities such as St. Gallen operate pilot models
→
Threshold: Interregional, portable time-credit systems
Recruitment into militia offices

Militia offices show whether citizens are willing to take on responsibility outside paid work. Persistent vacancies suggest that a load-bearing structure of meaning is breaking down. Where renewal succeeds, the militia system can give productive shape to newly freed time. The indicator provides an early read on whether Switzerland preserves or loses its institutional capital.

Today: Many municipalities report difficulty filling volunteer civic offices
→
Threshold: Widespread vacancies in municipal volunteer offices
06 · OPEN QUESTIONS

What we do not yet know

1. How can unpaid civic engagement be recognised in ways that genuinely redirect freed-up time into social contribution?
2. Can time-credit models be made portable across municipal boundaries and guaranteed over the long term?
3. What role should schools play in ensuring that identity is not defined solely by employability?
4. How does Switzerland strengthen the mental health of young people before labour-market transformation takes full effect?
← All pillars: overviewNext: 11 · Geopolitics & Locational Competitiveness →

What comes next